Skip to content

ExplainerElectionUnited States3 min read

Maine Democrats scramble to replace Platner as Shah faces Duckworth criticism

Maine Democrats race to replace Senate nominee Graham Platner as potential successor Nirav Shah faces criticism from Sen. Tammy Duckworth.

Share

Topics

Professional portrait of a man wearing glasses and a pink striped tie, seated in an office with framed photos on the wall.

WASHINGTON, July 11 (DC Times Online) — Maine Democrats are racing to settle a new Senate nominee after Graham Platner said he is suspending his campaign, a move that could force the party to choose a replacement before the filing deadline set by state election officials.

The contest matters because Democrats are trying to unseat Republican Sen. Susan Collins, and Platner’s exit has turned the race into a fast-moving replacement fight in Washington and Augusta.

What did Platner do?

In a video statement, Platner said, “We believe that for the movement to continue it can’t be me — and for that reason we are suspending campaign operations.” He also said he intends to file paperwork to withdraw from the ballot.

CNN reported that if Platner withdraws before 5 p.m. ET Monday, the Maine Democratic Party would have until July 27 to submit a replacement name to the secretary of state.

The Maine Democratic Party has already approved a plan to hold a nominating convention if Platner steps aside.

Who could replace him?

One name now in the mix is Nirav Shah, the former director of the Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention. CNN reported that Shah said he was evaluating whether to seek the Senate nomination, and The New York Times later reported that he formally declared his candidacy after Platner’s exit.

Shah is not the only possible contender. Other names reported as possible or active replacements include Troy Jackson, Shenna Bellows, Valli Geiger, Jordan Wood and Dan Kleban.

The party has not yet chosen a replacement nominee, and the reporting does not show a final roster of candidates.

Why is Shah drawing pushback?

Shah is facing criticism because of his past public health leadership in Illinois. The Washington Examiner reported that Sen. Tammy Duckworth of Illinois publicly opposed his Senate bid in a post on X.

Duckworth wrote, “Maine deserves better than someone who put his public image before the safety of our Veterans,” and added, “I called for his resignation then, and I strongly oppose his run for Senate now.”

Duckworth and Sen. Dick Durbin had called for Shah’s resignation in 2018 after investigations into a Legionnaires’ disease outbreak at the Illinois Veterans Home in Quincy. Reporting on that controversy said the outbreak killed at least 13 veterans and sickened dozens more while Shah was director of the Illinois Department of Public Health.

What was Shah’s role in Maine before this?

Shah also has been part of Maine’s own public health leadership. The New York Times and CNN reported that he previously led Maine’s coronavirus response as the state’s CDC director.

That background is part of why he is being discussed as a possible replacement. But it is also why his record is now under close review by Democrats weighing whether he could take Platner’s place in a race that still has to be formally settled.

What happens next?

The next steps depend on Platner’s filing and the party’s replacement process. If he withdraws in time, the Maine Democratic Party can name a new candidate before the state deadline. If not, the race could stay tied up in election paperwork.

For now, the important point is simple: Maine Democrats are not just choosing a nominee for November. They are trying to finish a sudden replacement contest while also confronting a public debate over whether Nirav Shah, a former health official with both supporters and critics, should be the person to take Platner’s place.

Share

Topics

Stacy Hughes

Stacy Hughes is Times Media Service's U.K. correspondent, based in London, England. Hughes covers arts and entertainment, beauty, business and finance, and crime and justice across the United Kingdom. Hughes grew up in Annapolis, Maryland, and holds a master's degree in film and media.

Write to Stacy